An appointment a court held unconstitutional
On June 16, 2025, Gianforte appointed Rep. Marta Bertoglio, who was elected to a House term that runs to January 2027, as Director of Commerce. On April 16, 2026, a district court held the appointment unconstitutional and ruled she may not serve or be paid. His office said the ruling was not effective until a procedural appeal ended and the case was remanded; that appeal failed on June 23, 2026, the case was remanded on July 9, and on August 14, 2026, his office still called her Commerce Director.
Status · On appeal The Governor has appealed the ruling (DA 26-0625), and the Montana Supreme Court let the appeal proceed on September 15, 2026. If it reverses, this count falls. We have not yet confirmed whether any court paused (stayed) the ruling after July 9. If one did, this count will be revised. No court has decided whether any of this violates his oath of office.
We believe the constitutional text is plain. He was told in writing before any lawsuit was filed, and a court held the appointment unconstitutional. After the appeal his office relied on failed, his office still presented her as director. We believe that puts his choice above the constitution he swore to support, protect and defend, and the petition will argue that this violates his oath.
Full record for Count I: what happened and sources
On June 16, 2025, Gianforte appointed Rep. Marta Bertoglio, who was elected to a House term that runs to January 2027, as Director of Commerce. The Montana Constitution bars appointing a legislator, “during the term for which he shall have been elected,” to “any civil office under the state.” He declined a July 10, 2025 written request to remove her. On April 16, 2026, District Judge Elizabeth Best held the appointment unconstitutional and ruled she may not serve or be paid. His office said the ruling was not effective until a procedural appeal ended. That appeal failed on June 23, and the case returned to the district court on July 9. On August 14, his office still called her Commerce Director.